1
00:00:00,240 --> 00:00:01,791
This is a Peltier element.

2
00:00:02,291 --> 00:00:05,427
It may look like a rather unassuming hunk of material,

3
00:00:05,427 --> 00:00:13,310
but sandwiched between these two plates are a whole bunch of semiconductor junctions that have been carefully arranged to do something remarkable:

4
00:00:13,310 --> 00:00:19,401
when I apply a DC voltage across these two wires, the plate becomes cold.

5
00:00:19,401 --> 00:00:24,342
This is called thermoelectric cooling,
and it’s happening thanks to the Peltier effect.

6
00:00:24,342 --> 00:00:30,194
With advances in manufacturing,
we are now able to produce these devices quickly and cheaply.

7
00:00:30,194 --> 00:00:33,317
These ones here cost less than $3 each.

8
00:00:33,317 --> 00:00:37,956
There’s just one little issue with this technology:

9
00:00:37,956 --> 00:00:40,090
it’s not very good.

10
00:00:40,090 --> 00:00:42,129
Like, at all.

11
00:00:42,129 --> 00:00:44,248
OK, we’re gonna need some context.

12
00:00:44,248 --> 00:00:46,611
I’m making this video for a couple of reasons:

13
00:00:46,611 --> 00:00:51,143
First, you may know about my one true love, the refrigeration cycle.

14
00:00:51,143 --> 00:00:56,339
I adore a good heat pump and could talk your ear off about them for hours on end,

15
00:00:56,339 --> 00:01:01,775
but vapor-compression based refrigeration systems are
bulky and mechanically complex affairs.

16
00:01:01,775 --> 00:01:06,137
They also have some environmental issues stemming from the refrigerants they use.

17
00:01:06,137 --> 00:01:10,697
Because of those downsides, with a regularity you could practically set a watch to

18
00:01:10,697 --> 00:01:16,423
well-meaning people discover Peltier elements
and question why we don’t use these instead.

19
00:01:16,423 --> 00:01:23,231
A device with no moving parts and which makes cooling happen simply by putting voltage across it does feel like the future!

20
00:01:23,231 --> 00:01:27,125
That’s gotta be better than all the faff 
we go through to build a fridge, right?

21
00:01:27,125 --> 00:01:29,991
Well, “better” is a slippery word.

22
00:01:29,991 --> 00:01:41,774
For one thing, the Peltier these are named for is Jean Charles Athanase Peltier,
and he discovered this phenomenon back in 1834.

23
00:01:41,774 --> 00:01:47,492
We’ve been taking cracks at this for a long time, yet it still hasn’t changed the world.

24
00:01:47,492 --> 00:01:52,041
It is true that this form of cooling offers some unique advantages

25
00:01:52,041 --> 00:02:00,221
and in very specific applications with equally specific design constraints,
using a Peltier element can make some sense.

26
00:02:00,221 --> 00:02:07,140
However, the situations in which these are truly appropriate to use are very, very rare.

27
00:02:07,140 --> 00:02:14,327
You will absolutely understand why that is by the end, but for now
(and this leads into the second reason I’m making this video)

28
00:02:14,327 --> 00:02:19,093
you should know that the majority of products on sale 
today which use these things

29
00:02:19,093 --> 00:02:25,434
are being made purely to capitalize on the fact that we just 
can’t stop ourselves from buying cheap crap.

30
00:02:25,434 --> 00:02:30,256
Speaking of cheap crap,
you’ve probably seen these little personal refrigerators before.

31
00:02:30,256 --> 00:02:35,946
The idea is you can keep a few cans of your favorite 
beverage cool on your desk!

32
00:02:35,946 --> 00:02:38,760
You’ll be the talk of the office, for sure!

33
00:02:38,760 --> 00:02:44,393
All of these things use Peltier elements to cool their insides for a very simple reason:

34
00:02:44,393 --> 00:02:45,566
cost.

35
00:02:45,566 --> 00:02:49,462
These have to be cheap enough for people to pick them up impulsively.

36
00:02:49,462 --> 00:02:53,296
And they are - this was priced just over $30.

37
00:02:53,296 --> 00:03:01,243
You can’t build a proper fridge that cheaply, but you can build a little plastic box
with a cheap power supply and $2 Peltier module in it.

38
00:03:01,243 --> 00:03:03,339
And people will buy it.

39
00:03:03,339 --> 00:03:05,786
Look, I’m a people, and I bought it!

40
00:03:05,786 --> 00:03:07,604
But is it any good?

41
00:03:07,604 --> 00:03:08,963
Spoiler alert:

42
00:03:08,963 --> 00:03:10,279
No!

43
00:03:10,279 --> 00:03:12,973
Let’s turn it on and put it through its paces!

44
00:03:12,973 --> 00:03:16,575
It has a power switch helpfully labeled “Off” and “Cold.”

45
00:03:16,575 --> 00:03:18,756
That's a sign of quality, that is.

46
00:03:18,756 --> 00:03:20,235
Here goes nothing!

47
00:03:20,235 --> 00:03:23,934
[a fan spins up]
Ooh, it’s even got an interior light! How thoughtful.

48
00:03:23,934 --> 00:03:28,521
But, uh, that’s a lot of noise for something with no moving parts.

49
00:03:28,521 --> 00:03:30,407
What gives?

50
00:03:30,407 --> 00:03:38,484
Well, the Peltier element itself doesn’t have any moving parts 
but when I showed you it in the beginning, I only showed one side of it.

51
00:03:38,484 --> 00:03:46,355
That side was getting cold, yes, and in this... alleged fridge
the cold side of the element is bonded to the rear wall

52
00:03:46,355 --> 00:03:49,776
which we can see getting cold in the thermal camera.

53
00:03:49,776 --> 00:03:57,542
But as the peltier element generates cooling on the one side,
the other side of the element gets hot.

54
00:03:57,542 --> 00:03:59,582
Very hot.

55
00:03:59,582 --> 00:04:01,954
Problematically hot.

56
00:04:01,954 --> 00:04:04,992
Why? Well, two reasons.

57
00:04:04,992 --> 00:04:13,139
Peltier modules produce cooling by absorbing heat on the cold side
and moving it through the element to the hot side.

58
00:04:13,139 --> 00:04:19,691
That’s how all cooling works - energy doesn’t just disappear,
so to lower the amount of heat energy in one location,

59
00:04:19,691 --> 00:04:23,957
you have to absorb it from that location and move it somewhere else.

60
00:04:23,957 --> 00:04:26,050
Which is exactly what these do.

61
00:04:26,050 --> 00:04:32,700
They absorb heat on this side (which to us feels like coldness)
and reject it on the hot side.

62
00:04:32,700 --> 00:04:40,723
But since the heat is only moving across
a thin little barrier with very little mass, it builds up really quickly.

63
00:04:40,800 --> 00:04:42,164
But that’s not all!

64
00:04:42,164 --> 00:04:45,781
The element itself creates heat as it runs.

65
00:04:45,781 --> 00:04:55,518
These here are rated 5 amps at 12 volts, so when running at full capacity
they’re dissipating 60 watts of heat in a really small space,

66
00:04:55,518 --> 00:04:59,710
and that’s on top of the heat it’s pulling from the cold side.

67
00:04:59,710 --> 00:05:06,775
So, to keep it from destroying itself, you need a finned heat sink 
bonded to the hot side to spread that heat out,

68
00:05:06,775 --> 00:05:12,721
and you’ll also need a fan to force air across the 
heat sink to spread the heat even more quicklier.

69
00:05:12,721 --> 00:05:20,639
And as we can see here, the itty bitty fridge 
has a generously sized heat sink hanging off the back with a fan blowing right at it.

70
00:05:20,639 --> 00:05:30,080
A fan and heat sink pair isn’t complicated or expensive,
but it means this is noisier than you might expect and, ya know, adds a moving part.

71
00:05:30,080 --> 00:05:33,979
But noise is forgivable, the real question is how well does it work?

72
00:05:33,979 --> 00:05:37,209
And the answer to that question is: not!

73
00:05:37,209 --> 00:05:41,420
And by every conceivable metric you can imagine.

74
00:05:41,420 --> 00:05:45,212
For a start, you may have noticed this has no temperature settings.

75
00:05:45,212 --> 00:05:47,698
It’s just cold or off.

76
00:05:47,698 --> 00:05:55,390
That’s because it only promises to lower the internal temperature
by up to 30 degrees below ambient temperature.

77
00:05:55,390 --> 00:05:57,122
That’s it.

78
00:05:57,122 --> 00:06:03,157
I appreciate its honesty, but if you know anything about food safety,
you’re gonna be getting the willies right now.

79
00:06:03,157 --> 00:06:09,600
Because in an office environment during the summertime where, say, the room temperature might be 75 degrees Fahrenheit,

80
00:06:09,600 --> 00:06:18,774
this thing will - at best - get the interior down to 45 degrees Fahrenheit which by US standards is not food safe.

81
00:06:18,774 --> 00:06:20,881
So… strike one.

82
00:06:20,881 --> 00:06:25,657
But ok, let’s say you just want to cool some 
beverages and you don’t care about food.

83
00:06:25,657 --> 00:06:31,157
Well, to see how well it manages that
I loaded it up fully with 6 room temperature beverage cans

84
00:06:31,157 --> 00:06:35,624
then shoved one of my temperature data loggers in the void space between them.

85
00:06:35,624 --> 00:06:41,207
After running for two hours, it hadn’t even gotten below 60 degrees inside here.

86
00:06:41,207 --> 00:06:45,588
After 12 hours it had only managed to drop to 48 degrees Fahrenheit,

87
00:06:45,588 --> 00:06:51,413
and after 24 hours the temperature had plateaued at about 46 degrees.

88
00:06:51,413 --> 00:06:53,924
Not very impressive.

89
00:06:53,924 --> 00:06:57,654
Somehow it got a bit of a second wind right near the 24 hour mark,

90
00:06:57,654 --> 00:07:01,626
which I believe happened just because the room it 
was in had cooled off a little,

91
00:07:01,626 --> 00:07:04,962
and we ended up bottoming out at 45.5 degrees.

92
00:07:04,962 --> 00:07:09,492
Which, in fairness, was about 30 degrees below the room temperature.

93
00:07:09,492 --> 00:07:14,494
So it did what it said it would, but it sure took ages to get there.

94
00:07:14,494 --> 00:07:22,113
However, I was measuring the air temperature in the center of the fridge and since the cans are all touching the sides,

95
00:07:22,113 --> 00:07:28,991
I found that the actual temperature of the liquid in those 
cans was a slightly warmer 50 degrees.

96
00:07:28,991 --> 00:07:32,663
Chilled, I suppose, but I wouldn’t want a beer that warm.

97
00:07:33,000 --> 00:07:35,578
So… strike two.

98
00:07:35,578 --> 00:07:38,377
But okay, so it’s not technically a refrigerator

99
00:07:38,377 --> 00:07:39,680
and it takes forever to cool down

100
00:07:39,680 --> 00:07:41,371
and it doesn’t keep things that cold

101
00:07:41,371 --> 00:07:43,507
and it’s louder than the box implies

102
00:07:43,507 --> 00:07:45,927
but that doesn’t mean it’s not useful!

103
00:07:45,927 --> 00:07:49,758
And to that I’d say, you’re not technically wrong!

104
00:07:49,758 --> 00:07:56,919
Some people use these things to keep certain cosmetic items in a cool, dry place, 
and from what I can tell they’re happy to have these!

105
00:07:56,919 --> 00:08:02,784
And if 50 degrees is cold enough for you, and you’re 
diligent about rotating cans in and out,

106
00:08:02,784 --> 00:08:06,611
you might actually enjoy this as a beverage cooler.

107
00:08:06,611 --> 00:08:09,835
But here comes strike three, and it’s a doozy

108
00:08:09,835 --> 00:08:13,649
(and also why Peltier devices are generally terrible).

109
00:08:13,649 --> 00:08:20,000
If you’re at all concerned with how much energy
this thing will use to do its job not very well,

110
00:08:20,000 --> 00:08:26,941
you should know that this thing consumes about 55 watts of power all the time.

111
00:08:26,941 --> 00:08:32,978
That’s not a ton of power, no, but guess what uses less power than that?

112
00:08:32,978 --> 00:08:36,598
Well, lots of things but most relevant to this discussion -

113
00:08:36,598 --> 00:08:39,433
an actual refrigerator.

114
00:08:39,433 --> 00:08:45,391
This here is what I call the standard cube fridge,
the most basic mini-fridge you can buy.

115
00:08:45,391 --> 00:08:52,751
They’re generally around $100 and while they are incredibly basic they are also actual refrigerators.

116
00:08:52,751 --> 00:08:59,283
We have a lil’ baby compressor back here pumping refrigerant 
through an honest-to-goodness refrigeration circuit.

117
00:08:59,283 --> 00:09:04,970
Now, it did cost significantly more money to purchase than the blue... thing,

118
00:09:04,970 --> 00:09:08,044
but it can also hold a lot more stuff.

119
00:09:08,044 --> 00:09:10,700
Including the blue fridge.

120
00:09:10,700 --> 00:09:16,224
By the internationally recognized metric of
“how many cans of La Croix can you shove in there per dollar”

121
00:09:16,224 --> 00:09:18,800
the real fridge wins by a lot.

122
00:09:18,800 --> 00:09:27,283
It’ll hold 33 cans easily, and 36 if you’re a little bit creative, 
which works out to $2.77 per can.

123
00:09:27,283 --> 00:09:35,080
And the blue fridge, despite only costing $30, 
only holds six cans so that’s $5 per can.

124
00:09:35,080 --> 00:09:36,727
But that’s not the real issue.

125
00:09:36,727 --> 00:09:41,735
Remember, the blue fridge uses 55 watts all the time.

126
00:09:41,735 --> 00:09:44,031
Guess how much power this thing uses?

127
00:09:44,031 --> 00:09:50,295
Once the refrigeration circuit has stabilized,
it pulls between 45 and 50 watts from the wall.

128
00:09:50,295 --> 00:09:58,618
I’ve consulted with some math scholars who have confirmed for me
that that figure is less than the 55 watts the stupid blue fridge pulls.

129
00:09:58,618 --> 00:10:00,192
But that’s not all!

130
00:10:00,192 --> 00:10:07,549
This, because it’s an actual refrigerator,
has a thermostat to maintain food safe temperatures inside!

131
00:10:07,549 --> 00:10:10,791
And that means it doesn’t run all the time.

132
00:10:10,791 --> 00:10:17,831
I monitored its energy use when loaded up with 15 already-chilled beverage cans,
and to keep them cool over three hours,

133
00:10:17,831 --> 00:10:24,706
it consumed just 65 watt-hours representing an average draw of 21.7 watts.

134
00:10:24,706 --> 00:10:30,000
And, by the way, the room it was in during that test was a pretty warm 78 degrees.

135
00:10:30,000 --> 00:10:32,267
Now, electricity isn’t free.

136
00:10:32,267 --> 00:10:35,075
So let’s do a little cost comparison.

137
00:10:35,075 --> 00:10:43,007
The blue fridge, with its constant 55 watt draw,
will consume 39.6 kilowatt-hours per month.

138
00:10:43,007 --> 00:10:52,228
Going by the average cost of electricity in the US of $0.14 per kilowatt-hour,
it will cost about $5.50 per month to use continuously.

139
00:10:52,228 --> 00:10:55,611
So about $66 a year.

140
00:10:55,611 --> 00:11:04,561
The much larger mini fridge, on the other hand,
drawing 22 watts continuously will consume 15.8 kilowatt-hours in a month,

141
00:11:04,561 --> 00:11:10,176
which costs $2.21 per month, or $27 bucks a year.

142
00:11:10,176 --> 00:11:13,589
That’s $39 less than the blue fridge per year,

143
00:11:13,589 --> 00:11:20,805
so it doesn’t even take two years of operation
for the extra $70 you spend on the real fridge to pay for itself.

144
00:11:21,423 --> 00:11:24,488
Seems like this blue fridge might be kind of bad!

145
00:11:24,488 --> 00:11:31,501
Now I could stop here, but I’m not gonna
because this thing's awful efficiency just gets funnier the more context you have.

146
00:11:31,501 --> 00:11:33,488
You remember this goofy thing.

147
00:11:33,488 --> 00:11:39,307
It’s moved into my office and has an actual
temperature controller now which fixes its major flaw.

148
00:11:39,307 --> 00:11:48,590
It’s still by no means a good refrigerator - stick a twelve pack
of room temperature cans in there and it runs nonstop for almost four hours.

149
00:11:48,590 --> 00:11:51,559
It’s really not built for making warm things cold.

150
00:11:51,559 --> 00:11:57,258
But as far as its ability to maintain food safe temperatures, it does the job just fine.

151
00:11:57,258 --> 00:11:59,708
And how much energy does it use?

152
00:11:59,708 --> 00:12:08,789
Well, after adding 6 room temperature beverage cans,
I measured its energy use over 24 hours and it needed only 970 watt-hours,

153
00:12:08,789 --> 00:12:12,557
meaning on average it only pulled 40.4 watts.

154
00:12:12,557 --> 00:12:16,778
Which, believe it or not, is less than 55.

155
00:12:16,778 --> 00:12:21,997
And that’s despite the rather pronounced
size difference between these two machines.

156
00:12:21,997 --> 00:12:23,928
I mean… just look at them!

157
00:12:23,928 --> 00:12:33,017
It’s frankly ridiculous that such a tiny little “fridge” is using more energy than the comparatively gigantic one next to it.

158
00:12:33,017 --> 00:12:36,492
In an earlier 24 hour test when the weather was a little cooler,

159
00:12:36,492 --> 00:12:47,673
the red fridge consumed just 890 watt-hours in 24 hours
while the stupid little blue one needed 1,290 watt hours over the same period.

160
00:12:47,673 --> 00:12:53,218
Because it’s always pulling 55 watts whenever it’s switched on.

161
00:12:53,218 --> 00:12:59,481
That’s 45% more energy spent only kind of cooling six cans.

162
00:12:59,481 --> 00:13:02,335
And ya know how many cans this sucker will hold?

163
00:13:02,335 --> 00:13:10,532
If you fill the crisper drawer, all the door shelves,
and double stack on the top shelf, it’ll hold 135 cans.

164
00:13:10,532 --> 00:13:19,816
It’ll take it forever to make them all cold but once they get there the fridge will use roughly the same 900 watt-hours per day keeping them all ice cold.

165
00:13:19,816 --> 00:13:23,547
Are you starting to understand why I keep calling this stupid junk?

166
00:13:23,547 --> 00:13:28,690
And let’s not forget the red fridge has a freezer compartment
for ice cream and pizza and stuff!

167
00:13:28,690 --> 00:13:36,748
Now, as I’ve covered before, mini-fridges are actually some of the 
least energy-efficient refrigerators out there thanks to their minimal insulation.

168
00:13:37,572 --> 00:13:43,253
And by the way, I need to clear something up for the 
Europeans who keep badgering me about this:

169
00:13:43,320 --> 00:13:46,467
I never said the red fridge was a mini-fridge!

170
00:13:46,467 --> 00:13:53,435
A bunch of you heard me say that somewhere
but I would never consider a fridge which goes up to my chest to be a mini-fridge.

171
00:13:53,435 --> 00:13:59,542
I called it little, and I called it a bit on the small side
but I also said, and I quote,

172
00:13:59,542 --> 00:14:06,095
“it’s much bigger than a typical mini-fridge
and served me well as a decently competent refrigerator.”

173
00:14:06,095 --> 00:14:13,680
At the very end of that video I did lump it into the category 
of mini-fridges because of its thin walls,  

174
00:14:13,680 --> 00:14:17,811
but that’s as close as I ever got to calling it a mini-fridge.

175
00:14:17,811 --> 00:14:22,151
Methinks your confirmation bias kicked in a little early and a little strong.

176
00:14:22,151 --> 00:14:25,085
Maybe those 230 volts are gettin’ to your head.

177
00:14:25,085 --> 00:14:28,100
But speaking of Americans and their giant American fridges,

178
00:14:28,100 --> 00:14:31,896
[banjo music starts]
at home I’ve got a GIANT AMERICAN FRIDGE!

179
00:14:31,896 --> 00:14:36,686
[said in a thick Southern accent]
My 360 pound behemoth (that’s 163 kilograms for you commies)

180
00:14:36,686 --> 00:14:39,942
features automatic defrost for maintenance-free operation,

181
00:14:39,942 --> 00:14:45,798
is plumbed to a water line for its built-in ice maker
because we want ice in our drinks, goshdarnit,

182
00:14:45,798 --> 00:14:53,813
and it has 16.35 All-American Cubic Feet of Fridge Capacity
and a 5.59 cubic foot freezer compartment.

183
00:14:53,813 --> 00:14:59,604
That’s 461 liters in the fridge and 158 litres in the freezer.

184
00:14:59,604 --> 00:15:03,376
And guess which of those two fridges uses more energy?

185
00:15:03,376 --> 00:15:05,795
THIS STUPID THING!

186
00:15:05,795 --> 00:15:12,468
Yes, according to government testing (I didn’t do my own, sorry about that)
my bottom-freezer, French door fridge

187
00:15:12,468 --> 00:15:15,405
(which are two dings against its energy efficiency),

188
00:15:15,405 --> 00:15:21,589
despite being able to hold over 50 times as 
much stuff before we even count the frozen food,

189
00:15:21,589 --> 00:15:30,115
and which features heated defrost uses slightly 
less energy over a year than it takes to run this toy.

190
00:15:30,115 --> 00:15:39,643
It needs 1,270 watt-hours per day to attain actual refrigeration
compared to the 1,290 this stupid thing used

191
00:15:39,643 --> 00:15:43,743
to keep six cans of la croix only kind of chilled.

192
00:15:43,743 --> 00:15:48,302
I ask again, are you starting to understand why I think these things are stupid junk?

193
00:15:48,302 --> 00:15:53,236
Side note, I used the Canadian energy stats because as I found out the last go-round,

194
00:15:53,236 --> 00:15:58,920
the American EnergyGuide label is very very 
pessimistic thanks to the way the tests are run.

195
00:15:59,680 --> 00:16:04,320
It includes a lot more food browsing 
in hot weather than I think is typical,  

196
00:16:04,320 --> 00:16:10,846
and the energy guide label for the red fridge was 
about 20% higher than my own stress testing.

197
00:16:10,846 --> 00:16:15,643
But even if we go with the 633 kWh annual figure,

198
00:16:15,643 --> 00:16:24,948
then my actual fridge uses only 35 percent more energy
for approximately 7,000 percent more refrigerated space

199
00:16:24,948 --> 00:16:27,313
with a freezer on top of that.

200
00:16:27,313 --> 00:16:29,518
Or, below it, actually.

201
00:16:29,518 --> 00:16:36,785
So, why is this blue lump of sadness 
so much less efficient than any of the refrigerators we’ve discussed?

202
00:16:36,785 --> 00:16:39,609
Because all the rest have…

203
00:16:39,609 --> 00:16:41,985
heat pumps!

204
00:16:41,985 --> 00:16:48,181
Now, very out of character for me, 
I’m going to keep my explanation of the refrigeration cycle pretty brief.

205
00:16:48,181 --> 00:16:49,130
Kind of brief.

206
00:16:49,130 --> 00:16:49,880
Brief-ish.

207
00:16:49,880 --> 00:16:52,650
But here’s why it’s such a big deal:

208
00:16:52,650 --> 00:16:58,878
a vapor-compression heat pump like the one we 
find in even this very cheap and basic mini-fridge

209
00:16:58,878 --> 00:17:05,202
can move more heat energy out of the fridge's interior
than it takes to run the heat pump.

210
00:17:05,202 --> 00:17:10,757
That may sound impossible,
but the compressor is the only thing in here doing any work,

211
00:17:10,757 --> 00:17:18,672
and all it’s doing is using an electric motor to 
spin some pumpy parts inside this enclosure which pressurizes a gas.

212
00:17:18,672 --> 00:17:22,395
In the case of this fridge, 
that’s literally the only thing it’s doing.

213
00:17:22,395 --> 00:17:28,765
All the rest of its parts are just pipes and tubes 
which are exposed to the air inside and out.

214
00:17:28,920 --> 00:17:31,744
The gas it’s compressing is called a refrigerant.

215
00:17:31,744 --> 00:17:36,089
Refrigerants are a category of gasses
that we’ve discovered (or sometimes engineered)

216
00:17:36,089 --> 00:17:41,153
that have really useful relationships between their pressure and their boiling point.

217
00:17:41,153 --> 00:17:47,263
This fridge, like most on the market today,
uses isobutane which at atmospheric pressure is a gas.

218
00:17:47,263 --> 00:17:56,284
But if you pressurize isobutane to about 80 PSI,
its boiling point shoots up to 110 degrees Fahrenheit.

219
00:17:56,284 --> 00:17:58,840
That’s much hotter than typical room temperatures,

220
00:17:59,360 --> 00:18:05,120
so if you feed that high pressure gas through 
some tubes that are exposed to ambient air,  

221
00:18:05,120 --> 00:18:12,794
the air will cool it down to the point that it can’t be a gas anymore
and it will spontaneously condense into a liquid.

222
00:18:12,794 --> 00:18:21,420
That condensing action releases a ton of heat energy because of a thing called
the latent heat of vaporization which to save time I am not getting into right now,

223
00:18:21,420 --> 00:18:25,389
but you can see this heat being released in the thermal camera.

224
00:18:25,389 --> 00:18:31,465
You can even make out the tubes the refrigerant is traveling through just below the surface of the fridge’s outer skin.

225
00:18:31,465 --> 00:18:37,560
Thanks to the pumping action of the compressor, 
the refrigerant is actively pushed through those tubes.

226
00:18:37,560 --> 00:18:43,485
At the entrance it’s purely hot gas
(and it’s hot because the compressor just compressed it),

227
00:18:43,485 --> 00:18:48,869
but as it makes its way through it sheds heat energy and begins to liquify.

228
00:18:48,869 --> 00:18:54,629
By the time it makes it to the end of the tube,
a slug of liquid refrigerant will have bunched up.

229
00:18:54,629 --> 00:19:00,676
Then, that liquid refrigerant gets sent through a restriction 
which limits the volume of fluid flow.

230
00:19:00,676 --> 00:19:07,806
Because of the restriction and the pumping action of the 
compressor, a pressure imbalance is maintained on either side.

231
00:19:07,806 --> 00:19:14,658
And once the liquid makes it through it finds itself inside the evaporator
where the pressure is very low,

232
00:19:14,658 --> 00:19:22,126
in fact so low that the boiling point of isobutane
plummets to something like -20 degrees Fahrenheit.

233
00:19:22,126 --> 00:19:29,510
Even the air inside a freezer is warmer than that,
which means there’s energy available to boil the refrigerant.

234
00:19:29,510 --> 00:19:35,709
That causes it to absorb latent heat energy which means it gets very, very cold.

235
00:19:35,709 --> 00:19:44,480
Once the refrigerant has completely boiled away and becomes a gas once more,
it finds itself back at the compressor and the whole thing starts over again.

236
00:19:44,480 --> 00:19:47,390
The gas it’s compressing is called a refrigerant.

237
00:19:47,390 --> 00:19:52,311
Refrigerants are a category of gasses that we’ve discovered
(or sometimes engineered) that —

238
00:19:52,311 --> 00:19:53,784
okay that’s enough of that.

239
00:19:53,784 --> 00:20:01,360
Key to understanding this process is that the refrigerant,
through boiling away, absorbs a lot of heat energy.

240
00:20:01,360 --> 00:20:04,528
That heat energy is then stored in the refrigerant.

241
00:20:04,528 --> 00:20:12,064
But, when we compress it and it condenses back into a liquid,
it releases the energy it had just absorbed.

242
00:20:12,064 --> 00:20:18,885
Since we’re in control of where that happens,
we can move heat energy from one place to another.

243
00:20:18,885 --> 00:20:24,090
In the case of a fridge,
we’re pumping the heat out of the fridge’s interior which cools it down

244
00:20:24,090 --> 00:20:27,189
and then releasing that heat to the outside air.

245
00:20:27,189 --> 00:20:33,685
And the only thing we’re doing to make that happen
is compress a gas and pushing it through some pipes.

246
00:20:33,685 --> 00:20:37,679
The refrigerant does the heat transfer stuff all on its own.

247
00:20:37,679 --> 00:20:45,087
That is how a vapor-compression heat pump is able to move 
more energy than the machine itself consumes.

248
00:20:45,087 --> 00:20:52,174
The heat moving capacity compared to its power draw
is a metric known as the coefficient of performance.

249
00:20:52,174 --> 00:20:55,827
Now, not many people calculate the COP of a fridge,

250
00:20:55,827 --> 00:21:04,106
but if I assume it has a COP of 3
then we get a threefold increase in cooling power compared to input power.

251
00:21:04,106 --> 00:21:13,857
In other words, the 45 watts of power this fridge pulls from the wall when it’s running
generates 135 watts of cooling power in the evaporator.

252
00:21:13,857 --> 00:21:17,979
That is why we bother with a compressor and all this piping and junk,

253
00:21:17,979 --> 00:21:20,942
it’s just really, really efficient.

254
00:21:20,942 --> 00:21:25,784
And that’s also why heat pumps for heating our homes are becoming such a big deal:

255
00:21:25,784 --> 00:21:31,243
just as there’s heat to be pulled out of a freezer,
there’s heat to be grabbed from the air outside.

256
00:21:31,243 --> 00:21:40,134
And so long as the COP of an operating heat pump is over 1,
we're getting some free heat compared to running an electric heating element.

257
00:21:40,134 --> 00:21:42,609
But anyway, this video isn't about that.

258
00:21:42,609 --> 00:21:48,984
Peltier elements, because they move heat from one side to the other, 
are technically heat pumps.

259
00:21:48,984 --> 00:21:52,532
And that means we can measure their coefficient of performance.

260
00:21:52,532 --> 00:22:01,883
But that’s tricky to do because unlike a vapor-compression heat pump, their efficiency will vary wildly depending on the temperature difference it’s fighting

261
00:22:01,883 --> 00:22:05,198
as well as how much current you’re shoving through it.

262
00:22:05,198 --> 00:22:07,754
Remember, this is really thin.

263
00:22:07,754 --> 00:22:13,227
And the materials used to construct this
conduct heat even when it’s not running at all,

264
00:22:13,227 --> 00:22:17,016
so the higher the temperature difference between the hot and cold sides,

265
00:22:17,016 --> 00:22:23,428
the more heat energy leaks through the element itself
and the less efficient it becomes.

266
00:22:23,428 --> 00:22:25,439
And the effect there is dramatic.

267
00:22:25,439 --> 00:22:33,743
On top of that, the more current you try to push through this,
the more heat it generates inside itself which also makes things worse.

268
00:22:33,743 --> 00:22:41,956
In theory, if everything is perfect and you can run these at very low current,
you can get a COP between 1 and 2.

269
00:22:41,956 --> 00:22:50,964
But that will hardly generate any cooling at all, so in practice,
the COP of a device using a Peltier element for cooling

270
00:22:50,964 --> 00:22:54,384
is somewhere between zero and very bad.

271
00:22:54,384 --> 00:23:01,326
And that’s why this stupid little blue fridge
is using so much more energy than this actual fridge.

272
00:23:01,326 --> 00:23:02,813
Or that actual fridge.

273
00:23:03,078 --> 00:23:05,259
Or THAT actual fridge.

274
00:23:05,259 --> 00:23:08,686
Now, in fairness, there is more going on here.

275
00:23:08,686 --> 00:23:14,435
Its reliance on the Peltier effect is of course
the major factor in this fridge’s terrible efficiency,

276
00:23:14,435 --> 00:23:17,295
but it’s also got a lot to do with its design.

277
00:23:17,295 --> 00:23:25,486
Any actual fridge is subject to regulations 
which mean it has to have enough insulation in its walls to pass performance tests.

278
00:23:25,486 --> 00:23:32,299
The blue toy is a toy, and honestly I could barely even detect any insulation at all!

279
00:23:32,299 --> 00:23:34,586
The walls all feel hollow.

280
00:23:34,586 --> 00:23:42,013
So I drilled some exploratory holes and determined
that it does have what appears to be Styrofoam in the side walls

281
00:23:42,013 --> 00:23:44,920
but the door is in fact hollow.

282
00:23:44,920 --> 00:23:46,438
That’s great.

283
00:23:46,438 --> 00:23:55,120
If this had more insulation it could probably get its insides cooler using less energy,
but it would then also need some sort of temperature control.

284
00:23:55,120 --> 00:24:00,134
I think it’s actually relying on heat intrusion 
through the door to keep things from freezing.

285
00:24:00,134 --> 00:24:02,970
But any time you’re using a Peltier element,

286
00:24:02,970 --> 00:24:11,763
even the best designs with lots of thermal insulation are going to
run into the fundamental problem of a terrible coefficient of performance.

287
00:24:11,763 --> 00:24:19,143
These are just not very good at what they’re supposed to do
and will always lose a fight with a grown-up heat pump.

288
00:24:19,143 --> 00:24:24,134
And, not for nothing, while people fixate on the harm refrigerants cause

289
00:24:24,134 --> 00:24:30,167
(because they have been truly awful to the environment
and many in use today still are in one way or another)

290
00:24:30,167 --> 00:24:33,752
isobutane is not really a problem at all.

291
00:24:33,752 --> 00:24:39,147
It’s flammable which presents some practical challenges,
especially when the systems require service,

292
00:24:39,147 --> 00:24:45,660
but it has a global warming potential of only 3.3
and its other environmental effects are negligible.

293
00:24:45,660 --> 00:24:48,111
Plus, there’s hardly any of it in a fridge.

294
00:24:48,111 --> 00:24:52,514
Even my big one at home has a refrigerant charge of just 55 grams.

295
00:24:52,514 --> 00:24:58,354
So when it comes to domestic refrigerators,
you honestly don’t need to be worried about that anymore.

296
00:24:58,440 --> 00:25:06,235
You may remember, though, that I did say Peltier elements
have some very specific advantages in very specific applications.

297
00:25:06,235 --> 00:25:12,195
I’ve already covered the main one - if you need some cooling as cheaply as possible, they are an option.

298
00:25:12,195 --> 00:25:18,157
You just have to be aware of how energy-intensive they are
and decide whether that trade-off is worth it.

299
00:25:18,157 --> 00:25:20,558
And sometimes it might be!

300
00:25:20,558 --> 00:25:28,181
If, for example, you’re only using something occasionally,
the poor efficiency of these things might not matter that much.

301
00:25:28,181 --> 00:25:32,361
One example would be a portable cooler you can bring with you in the car.

302
00:25:32,361 --> 00:25:38,885
If it’s only ever going to be used on occasional car rides,
and it’s got the energy source of a car to supply it,

303
00:25:38,885 --> 00:25:41,696
its energy efficiency isn’t that critical.

304
00:25:41,696 --> 00:25:46,058
And portability is another area where Peltier elements can shine.

305
00:25:46,058 --> 00:25:51,854
The elements themselves weigh almost nothing,
and even finished products are quite light.

306
00:25:51,854 --> 00:25:57,850
This little thing doesn’t even weigh 4 pounds
(it’s 1.68 kilograms to be precise in metric fashion).

307
00:25:57,850 --> 00:26:03,069
Meanwhile the mini-fridge,
despite having the most adorable little compressor I’ve ever seen,

308
00:26:03,069 --> 00:26:07,505
weighs a much heftier 33 pounds (15 kilograms).

309
00:26:07,505 --> 00:26:14,668
In fairness the bulk of its weight isn’t from the refrigeration circuit,
just the metal parts that make up its body and frame and the door,

310
00:26:14,668 --> 00:26:17,099
but it’s still a pretty huge difference.

311
00:26:17,099 --> 00:26:22,411
And when it comes to portability, 
vapor-compression based systems have an Achille's heel:

312
00:26:22,411 --> 00:26:25,229
they are orientation-sensitive.

313
00:26:25,229 --> 00:26:32,929
The compressor that’s inside this little black ball is made of metal parts
which rub against each other and thus need lubrication,

314
00:26:33,000 --> 00:26:40,124
and to provide that lubrication (and also cooling
for the windings of the electric motor) the system has oil in it.

315
00:26:40,124 --> 00:26:47,208
The compressor housing forms an oil sump,
and we rely on gravity to keep that oil pooled in the bottom of the sump

316
00:26:47,208 --> 00:26:51,497
so that the compressor has the lubrication and cooling that it requires.

317
00:26:51,497 --> 00:27:00,911
And Earth’s gravity, famously, only ever pulls things towards the center of the Earth,
so you have to have this upright for it to work without destroying itself.

318
00:27:01,382 --> 00:27:09,286
And, if you move anything with a refrigeration compressor in it 
and you aren’t 100% sure it stayed upright as you moved it,

319
00:27:09,286 --> 00:27:18,171
you need to let these sit upright for at least a few hours before you switch them on
so any oil that might have gone somewhere it shouldn’t can drain back to the sump

320
00:27:18,171 --> 00:27:23,397
(many manufacturers will tell you to wait a full 24 hours
before switching them on after they've been moved).

321
00:27:24,040 --> 00:27:29,064
Peltier elements,
because they don't have any mechanical parts, don’t care about that!

322
00:27:29,064 --> 00:27:31,655
You can operate this fridge however you like,

323
00:27:31,655 --> 00:27:34,910
though of course you need to make sure the cooling vents aren’t blocked,

324
00:27:34,910 --> 00:27:37,477
and you'll never have to wait to switch it on after you move it.

325
00:27:37,477 --> 00:27:38,785
It’s always ready.

326
00:27:38,785 --> 00:27:43,150
And Peltier elements also have one last trick up their sleeves:

327
00:27:43,150 --> 00:27:47,939
when you reverse the polarity, they move heat in the opposite direction!

328
00:27:47,939 --> 00:27:52,762
That means you can offer a device which both heats and cools quite trivially.

329
00:27:52,762 --> 00:27:58,502
In fact, heated and cooled cupholders in cars is one application for this in real life.

330
00:27:58,668 --> 00:28:03,177
You can bond a Peltier element to a thermally conductive 
ring surrounding a cup holder

331
00:28:03,177 --> 00:28:06,439
(and use some sort of heat spreader for the other side of the element)

332
00:28:06,439 --> 00:28:11,856
and you can keep hot drinks hot or cold drinks cold just by flipping a switch.

333
00:28:11,856 --> 00:28:15,832
But, in all honesty, that’s mostly a gimmick.

334
00:28:15,832 --> 00:28:21,405
I saw it at the auto show when I was maybe 12 
and it hasn’t taken the world by storm yet.

335
00:28:21,405 --> 00:28:23,337
But back to the present.

336
00:28:23,337 --> 00:28:30,471
When the design requirements of very cheap to build,
easily portable, and only occasional use all collide,

337
00:28:30,471 --> 00:28:34,731
using Peltier elements for cooling makes some sense.

338
00:28:34,731 --> 00:28:44,177
But if this is going into something that’s going to be in anything close to continuous use and energy efficiency matters either for cost or scarcity reasons,

339
00:28:44,177 --> 00:28:46,792
it just doesn’t make any sense at all.

340
00:28:46,792 --> 00:28:52,424
There is in fact a very good reason refrigeration 
is still happening the way it always has.

341
00:28:52,424 --> 00:28:57,174
And if you’re looking at a product like this and thinking that might be useful,

342
00:28:57,174 --> 00:29:03,696
I would highly suggest you think long and hard about
whether one of these cube fridges might fit your needs.

343
00:29:03,696 --> 00:29:11,748
No, they’re not going to fit on your desk (at least not easily)
but they’ll do a lot more for you using a lot less energy.

344
00:29:11,748 --> 00:29:16,428
And these, too, can be had in all sorts of 
goofy colors if you look in the right places.

345
00:29:16,428 --> 00:29:23,033
That said… I would be remiss if I didn’t mention 
the big downside to some of these, including this model:

346
00:29:23,033 --> 00:29:28,994
ice builds up on the evaporator over time
and so this needs occasional defrosting.

347
00:29:28,994 --> 00:29:34,431
Depending on what you’re using it for that might be very rare
but it’s something to keep in mind.

348
00:29:34,431 --> 00:29:41,699
However, there are also plenty of these out there which have 
rear-mounted, vertical evaporators and skip the freezer compartment entirely,

349
00:29:41,699 --> 00:29:44,021
and those don’t need defrosting.

350
00:29:44,021 --> 00:29:47,944
I would honestly seek one of those out if you’re looking for a mini-fridge like this.

351
00:29:47,944 --> 00:29:52,602
Honestly the freezer compartment in here is pretty useless and just eats up space.

352
00:29:52,602 --> 00:29:55,780
The only reason I grabbed this one was because it was on sale at Menards.

353
00:29:55,780 --> 00:29:59,571
Only $80 and you know I mailed in that 11% rebate!

354
00:29:59,571 --> 00:30:04,905
And speaking of cheap things from Menards, 
I should say this particular model has a few annoyances.

355
00:30:04,905 --> 00:30:08,984
Its compressor is oddly buzzy, which is disappointing.

356
00:30:08,984 --> 00:30:15,740
The red fridge is actually quieter than the thermoelectric fridge, 
but this baby fridge is louder.

357
00:30:15,740 --> 00:30:20,674
There’s a good chance I just drew the short straw there
and most of these have quieter compressors,

358
00:30:20,674 --> 00:30:24,116
and besides I don’t think it would really be very annoying under a desk.

359
00:30:24,116 --> 00:30:26,364
But… something to mention.

360
00:30:26,364 --> 00:30:33,583
What actually worries me about this model is the fact that the thermostat
runs very, very short cycles.

361
00:30:33,583 --> 00:30:39,577
Like, once it’s down to temp it runs for 2 or 3 minutes and then stops for 3 or 4.

362
00:30:39,577 --> 00:30:43,293
That’s usually not the healthiest thing for a refrigeration compressor.

363
00:30:43,293 --> 00:30:48,494
But in this case, because of the design here,
I actually think that’s on purpose.

364
00:30:48,494 --> 00:30:54,439
Since the interior is so tiny, 
you’re going to end up with stuff right against the evaporator,

365
00:30:54,439 --> 00:31:00,343
so if it were to run for too long at once 
it would likely freeze some stuff on the top shelf.

366
00:31:00,343 --> 00:31:04,902
But anyway, now we’re just shopping for mini-fridges so I think I should wrap it up.

367
00:31:04,902 --> 00:31:13,105
The bottom line of this video is that Peltier elements are interesting and cool devices 
but they're just not good for general purpose cooling.

368
00:31:13,105 --> 00:31:18,312
And since we’ve adopted isobutane as the standard 
refrigerant in domestic refrigerators,

369
00:31:18,312 --> 00:31:22,808
to be honest you can stop feeling guilty about bringing another fridge into the world.

370
00:31:22,808 --> 00:31:26,355
I mean, you probably shouldn't buy one unless you actually need it

371
00:31:26,355 --> 00:31:32,944
(and I’m 50/50 on whether I’m gonna keep this for storing my color film
or donate it so someone else can make better use of it).

372
00:31:32,944 --> 00:31:38,262
But really this is just a cooler which happens to have a little heat pump in it.

373
00:31:38,262 --> 00:31:41,907
The steel and copper in here is the only special sauce.

374
00:31:41,907 --> 00:31:44,467
Ooh, I could keep sauce in here!

375
00:31:45,232 --> 00:31:47,798
♫ inefficiently smooth jazz ♫

376
00:31:49,476 --> 00:31:53,132
It may look like the teleprompter hasn’t started but that’s cuz it hasn’t.

377
00:31:53,132 --> 00:31:56,740
Which to us feels like coldness, and reject ahh..

378
00:31:56,740 --> 00:31:57,240
[clears throat]

379
00:31:57,240 --> 00:31:58,896
ehbutehbuDEDABAH

380
00:31:58,896 --> 00:32:02,056
Because all the rest have…

381
00:32:02,056 --> 00:32:04,061
HEAT PUUUuuUuuUUUumps.

382
00:32:04,061 --> 00:32:05,436
Woah that was not good.

383
00:32:05,436 --> 00:32:07,801
Even if we go with the 633

384
00:32:07,801 --> 00:32:09,616
kilowattanggguhbuhdeblledyaghbleurf

385
00:32:09,616 --> 00:32:11,578
Even when it's not running at all.

386
00:32:11,578 --> 00:32:16,021
So the higher temperature difference between the cot and…

387
00:32:16,021 --> 00:32:16,933
dah.

388
00:32:16,933 --> 00:32:21,639
..american energyguide label is very very pessimistic thanks to the way the depart oh…

389
00:32:21,639 --> 00:32:24,031
debeduh debeduh debbity duh

390
00:32:24,031 --> 00:32:28,074
It’s flammable which presents some practical challenges especially when

391
00:32:28,074 --> 00:32:32,373
ssssssssssssssssshhhwhww

392
00:32:32,373 --> 00:32:33,291
welp.

393
00:32:34,881 --> 00:32:36,610
So I think we can sum this up pretty well:

394
00:32:36,610 --> 00:32:38,423
Peltier elements? Not cool.

395
00:32:38,423 --> 00:32:40,649
Oh except they are... on the one side.

396
00:32:40,649 --> 00:32:42,632
But not cool as in, like, good.

397
00:32:42,632 --> 00:32:44,228
Or hip.

398
00:32:44,228 --> 00:32:47,024
Or rizz. Is that what the kids say now?

399
00:32:47,024 --> 00:32:49,214
oh no I looked it up and that is NOT RIGHT

400
00:32:49,214 --> 00:32:52,335
skibidi heat pump